Effectiveness of
Pranayama on Anxiety among Alcoholics in a Selected
De-addiction Centre
at Chennai
Mr. Muniyandi S.
Assistant Professor, Psychiatric Mental
Health Nursing, Kasturba Nursing College, Kasturba Health Society, Sevagram,
Wardha
Corresponding Author Email: muniyandi4u@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
The reduction of level of anxiety among alcoholics in de-addiction
center has an important role to play in enabling effectiveness of pranayama
intervention as an independent nursing intervention. The objective of the study
was to evaluate the effectiveness of pranayama on reduction of anxiety level
among alcoholics. The research design adopted was quasi-experimental pre-test,
post-test design. The conceptual framework for this study was based on modified
Irvin Rosen stock’s health belief and personal health behavioral model 1966.
The study has been conducted in wisdom hospital de-addiction center at Chennai.
on probability purposive sampling technique has been adopted to select the
desired sample. The total sample size was 60, of which 30 samples each in both
in experimental group and control group. As an intervention 15 minutes of
Pranayamawas administered for samples. The data was collected through state
trait anxiety inventory scale.The collected data were analyzed by using both
descriptive and inferential statistical methods. Paired ‘t’ test was used to
evaluate the effectiveness of pranayama on level of anxiety among alcoholics.
The obtained‘t’ value was 23.69. The findings of the study revealed that
pranayama helps in decreasing the level of anxiety among alcoholics.
KEY WORDS: Effectiveness, level of anxiety, alcoholics, de-addiction center,
pranaayama.
INTRODUCTION:
The World Health Organization defines
mental health as “a state of well being in which the individual realizes his or
her own abilities, can cope with the normal stresses of life, can work
productively and fruitfully, and is able to make a contribution to his or her
community (2005).Most people experience feelings of anxiety before an important
event such as exam, business presentation or first date. Anxiety disorders,
however, are illnesses. That causes people to feel frightened, distressed and
uneasy for no apparent reason if Left untreated, these disorders can
dramatically reduce productivity and significantly diminish an individual's
quality of life.
Anxiety disorders are among the most common mental
illnesses in America more than 40 million were affected by this debilitating
illness each year. Anxiety is a feeling of nervousness, apprehension, fear, or
worry. Some fears and worries are justified, such as worry about a loved one or
in an anticipation of taking a quiz, test or other examination.B4 Anxiety
interferes with the sufferer's ability to sleep or other day to day function.
It is noteworthy that teenagers are particularly susceptible to having
irritability as a symptom of a number of emotional problems, including anxiety.
Anxiety may occur without a cause, or it may occur based on a real situation
but may be out of proportion to what would normally be expected. Severe anxiety
can have a serious impact on daily life. Anxiety can be accompanied by a
variety of physical symptoms. Most commonly, these symptoms are related to the
heart, lungs, nervous, and gastrointestinal systems. You may have upset
stomach, diarrhea, trouble breathing, feel as if you may faint or are having a
heart attack.
It is common for an anxiety disorder to accompany another
anxiety disorder, including such illnesses as substance abuse. Anxiety
disorders can also coexist with physical disorders. In such instances, these
disorders will also need to be treated, before undergoing any treatment, it is
important to have a thorough medical check up to rule out other possible
causes. We need strong public acknowledgment that severe anxiety is the basis
for many of the most pervasive psychiatric disorders, and we need a public
outcry for research into the stressors that underlie anxiety disorders. This is
the only pathway to for the better treatments. Though drowning your sorrows in
a bottle may temporarily allow you to forget your worries, numerous studies
shows that you may be doing more harm than good when turning to alcohol for
anxiety relief.B12 According to the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and
Alcoholism drinking alcoholic beverages stimulates production of the same
hormones that your body releases when under anxiety. In other words, anxiety is
induced rather than reduced.
For a minority of people social drinking can gradually
deteriorate into alcohol abuse and eventually into alcohol dependenceB12. The
drinking could have started in a lot of different ways, but that’s not what’s
important. What is important is that the drinking became a habit and the habit
became alcohol dependence or alcoholism. It matters not a hoot whether the
alcohol is in the form of beer, wine or hard liquor. Alcoholism, also known as
alcohol dependence, is a disease that includes the following four symptoms.
Craving – a strong need, or urge, to drink. Loss of control -not being able to
stop drinking once drinking has begun. The Physical dependence - Withdrawal
symptoms are nausea, sweating, shakiness, and anxiety after stopping drinking,
tolerance - The need to drink greater amounts of alcohol to get “high.”There is
no “common” look for alcoholics you may be old or young; male or female;
single, married, divorced, widowed or living with someone; practice any
religion or none; live in the country, city, or suburb; earn a lot or a little;
come from any ethnic, cultural, or racial background; have any level of
education; and live any type of lifestyle and work.
Alcohol abuse and alcoholism cut across gender, race, and
nationality. Nearly14 million peoples in the United States-1 in every 13
adults--abuse alcohol and 19,171 persons died of alcohol-induced causes.
Alcohol problems are highest among young adults ages 18-29 and lowest among
adults in age 65 and above. It has been proven that people who start drinking
at an early age, 14 or younger, have an increased chance to develop alcohol
problems at some point in their lives.
India is one of the largest producers of alcohol in the
world and there India is one of the largest producers of alcohol in the world
and there has been a steady increase in its production over the last 15 years,
according to new statistics. India is a dominant producer of alcohol in
South-East Asia, with 65 per cent of the total share, and contributes to around
7 per cent of the total alcohol beverage imports into the region. More than
two-thirds of the total beverage alcohol consumption in the region is in India,
according to figures in the newly-compiled Alcohol Atlas of India .There
has been a steady increase in production in the country. Production doubled from
887.2 million liters in 1992-93 to 1,654 million liters in 1999-2000. It was
expected to treble to 2,300 million liters by 2007-08. (The Hindu 2008)
According to researcher personal experience most of the
people are vulnerable to anxiety. They use proper compensatory mechanism it
relived. But lack of adequate compensatory mechanism and divertional therapies
leads to addiction takes place; it may be alcoholism and drug abuse. So use
proper compensatory mechanism will help to lead a quality life. Pranayama is a
One of the simple and convenient method without any side effects to reduce
anxiety among alcoholics.
STATEMENT
OF THE PROBLEM:
Effectiveness of Pranayama on Anxiety among Alcoholics in a
Selected De Addiction Centre at Chennai.
OBJECTIVES
OF THE STUDY:
● To evaluate the effectiveness of pranayama on level
of anxiety among alcoholics.
● To determine the association between level of
anxiety among alcoholics with their selected demographic variables (Age,
Religion, education, marital status, type of family, occupation, monthly
income, duration of addiction).
HYPOTHESES:
H1: Pranayama is effective in reducing the anxiety among
the alcoholics.
H2: There is a statistically significant association
between level of anxiety among alcoholics with their selected demographic
variables. (age, religion, education, marital status, type of family,
occupation, monthly income, duration of addiction).
OPERATIONAL
DEFINITIONS:
Effectiveness:
It refers to the outcome of pranayama in terms of reduction
in the level of anxiety among alcoholics.
Alcoholics:
A person who consumes excessive alcohol and becomes addict.
Anxiety:
A state of apprehension, tension or uneasiness that stems
from the anticipation of danger, which may be internal or external. A person is
said to have anxiety when he/she scores between 41-120 in State trait anxiety
inventory.
Pranayama:
A type of yogic breathing exercise which consists of four
steps:
1. Inspiration, end inspiration
2. Breath holding
3. Expiration, end expiration
4. Breath holding
Time ratio 4: 4: 6: 2 (10 breathe cycle)
20 second rest for each cycle, 15 minutes once in a day.
Assumptions:
● Pranayama has a strong influence on anxiety among
alcoholics
● Pranayama is a simple measure to reduce anxiety
among alcoholics
● Pranayama improves physical and mental wellbeing of
clients with alcoholics.
Delimitations:
The study is delimited to the alcoholics who were admitted
in a selected Deaddiction center at Chennai.
Projected outcome
● The study will help the nurses to assess the level
of anxiety among alcoholics.
● The study will help the nurses to identify the
effectiveness of pranayama on reducing anxiety among alcohol.
● The study findings will help the nurses to practice
the pranayama as an intervention for reducing anxiety among alcoholics.
Research literature were reviewed and
organized under the following headings.
● Alcoholics with anxiety.
● Effectiveness of Pranayama technique on anxiety.
● Effectiveness of Pranayama on anxiety among
alcoholics
Conceptual Framework:
The conceptual framework for the study was developed on the
basis of Irwin Rosen stock’s Belief and Personal Health Behavioral model, one
of the most influential psychological approaches designed to account for the
ways in which healthy people seek to avoid illness.B14 This model postulates
that the health seeking behavior is influenced by a person’s perception of a
threat posed by health problems and the values associated with actions named at
reducing the threat within the framework.
Human behavior is seen as being dependent upon two
primary variables:
The value placed by a person upon a particular
outcome.
The person’s beliefs that a given action will
result in particular outcome.
INDIVIDUAL PERCEPTION |
|
MODIFYING FACTORS |
|
LIKELIHOOD OF ACTION |
|
PRECEIVED
BENEFITS OF ACTIN |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Accordingly the Health Belief Model suggest that preventive
action taken by an individual to avoid disease is due to particular individual
perception that he or she is personally susceptible and the occurrence of the
disease would have at least some severe personal implication.B9 The assumption
in this model is if we take particular actions susceptibility would be reduced
or the severity of the disease would be reduced. The model comprises of three
components with different variables:
METHODOLOGY:
Research Approach
A Quantitative approach was used for analyzing the
effectiveness of pranayama on reducing anxiety among alcoholics.
Research Design
According to Polit and Hungler., (2004) “Quasi-experimental
design involves the manipulation of an independent variable that is,
institution of an intervention. Quasi-experiment however lacks either the
randomization or control group features that characterize true experiments”.
Random selection and randomization was not adopted as it was not possible to
have the entire listing of anxiety among alcoholic clients, hence this design
was chosen.
A quasi experimental pre-test and post-test design with
control group was chosen for this study without randomization. Assessment was
made before and after the intervention (Pranayama) with State Trait Anxiety
Inventory. (STAI)
The diagrammatic representation of research design is given
below.
Group |
Pre test |
Intervention |
Post test |
|||||
Days |
||||||||
01 |
02 |
03 |
04 |
05 |
06 |
|||
Experimental
group |
O1 |
X |
X |
X |
X |
X |
X |
O2 |
Control
group |
O3 |
* |
* |
* |
* |
* |
* |
O4 |
(O1-O2) = Effectiveness of Pranayama
intervention.
Keys
O1- pre test assessment of level of anxiety in
experimental group
O2- post test assessment of level of anxiety in
control group
O3- pre test assessment of level of anxiety in
control group
O4- post test assessment of level of anxiety in
control group
X - Intervention (Pranayama)
* - Routine nursing care
Variables
Dependent Variable: Level of anxiety
Independent Variable: Pranayama (SKY)
Extraneous Variables: (Age, Religion, education, marital
status, type of family, Occupation, monthly income, duration of addiction)
The Schematic Representation of Research
Methodology
Description of Tool
The tool for the study has two sections
Section A: Demographic variables
Section B: State – Trait Anxiety Inventory, Spielberger
(1979)
Scoring Procedure
A tool had two parts state level and trait level anxiety
each part had 20 questions
Totally
40 questions
A total
raw score = 160
Mild
score = 41-80
Moderate
= 81-120
Severe =
121-160
Pranayama Intervention Technique
“Pranayama involves the regulation of the exhalation, the
inhalation, and the suspension of the breath. The regulation of these 3
processes is achieved by modulating their length and maintaining this
modulation for a period of time, as well as directing the mind into the
process. These components of breathing must be both long and uniform” (Yoga
Sutra). Like the arteries that carry blood throughout our physical body, our
energetic (subtle) body has the nadis (meridians) that are like rivers carrying
prana throughout the body. By directing the energy flow into our subtle body,
pranayama helps to awaken the nadis. This energizes the seven chakras that are
the centers of purification, storage and distribution of prana in the physical
body.
Data analysis and interpretation
The collected data regarding effectiveness of Pranayama on
level of anxiety Among alcoholics were organized, analyzed and interpreted as
follows
Section I: Data on
Demographic Variables of Alcoholics
Section II: Level of
anxiety among Alcoholics
Section III: Effectiveness of Pranayama on level of anxiety
among Alcoholics
Section IV: Association between the level of anxiety among
Alcoholics with Selected Demographic Variables.
Section I: Data on Demographic Variables of Alcoholics
Table 1:
Frequency and Percentage Distribution of Demographic Variables of
Alcoholics in Experimental and Control
group N=60
S No |
Demographic
Variables |
Experimental
Group |
Control
Group |
Total |
|||
n |
% |
n |
% |
N |
% |
||
1 |
Age in
years a) Less
than 18 b) 19 -
25 c)
26 - 40 d) 41
& above |
3 5 12 10 |
10 16.67 40 33.33 |
4 4 12 10 |
13.33 13.33 40 33.34 |
7 9 24 20 |
11.67 15 40 33.33 |
2 |
Religion a) Hindu b) Muslim c)Christian d)Others |
25 2 3 0 |
83.33 6.67 10 0 |
21 5 4 0 |
70 16.67 13.33 0 |
46 7 7 0 |
76.66 11.67 11.67 0 |
3 |
Education a)Primary b)Higher
Secondary c)Graduate |
15 7 8 |
50 23.33 26.67 |
15 10 5 |
50 33.33 16.67 |
30 17 13 |
50 28.33 21.67 |
4 |
Marital
Status a)Married b)Unmarried c)Divorce |
14 11 5 |
46.67 36.67 16.66 |
17 12 1 |
56.67 40 3.33 |
31 23 6 |
51.67 38.33 10 |
5 |
Type Of
Family a)Joint
Family b)Nuclear
Family |
12 18 |
40 60 |
16 14 |
53.33 46.67 |
28 32 |
46.67 53.33 |
6 |
Occupation a)Self
Employee b)Employed c)Un
employed |
20 10 0 |
66.67 33.33 0 |
12 18 0 |
40 60 0 |
32 28 0 |
53.33 46.67 0 |
7 |
Monthly
Income In Rupees a)Less
Than 2000 b)2001 -
3000 c)3001 -
4000 d)4000 And Above |
4 7 2 17 |
13.33 22.33 6.67 56.67 |
0 3 11 16 |
0 10 36.67 53.33 |
4 10 13 33 |
6.67 16.67 21.66 55 |
8 |
Duration
Of Alcoholism a)Less
than one year b)2 -
3Years c)4 -
5Years d)Above 5
Years |
5 6 5 14 |
16.67 20 16.67 46.66 |
3 11 13 3 |
10 36.67 43.33 10 |
8 17 18 17 |
13.33 28.33 30 28.34 |
Section II :
Level of anxiety among Alcoholics
Table
2.1Frequency and percentage distribution of level of anxiety among alcoholics
in experimental group
S. No. |
Level of anxiety |
Pretest |
Post test |
||
n |
% |
n |
% |
||
1 |
Normal` |
0 |
0 |
5 |
16.67 |
2 |
Mild |
6 |
20 |
21 |
70 |
3 |
Moderate |
24 |
80 |
4 |
13.33 |
Fig 3.1 Level of anxiety
among alcoholics in experimental group
Table 2.1 shows the frequency and percentage distribution
of level of anxiety among alcoholics in an experimental group.
Fig. 3.2 Level of
anxiety among alcoholics in Control group
Table 2.2 Frequency and percentage
distribution on level of anxiety in control group
S. No. |
Level of anxiety |
Pretest |
Post test |
||
n |
% |
n |
% |
||
1 |
Normal` |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
2 |
Mild |
7 |
23.33 |
7 |
23.33 |
3 |
Moderate |
23 |
76.67 |
23 |
76.67 |
Table 3 Mean,
standard deviation, mean deviation, and `t value for experimental and control
group
S. No. |
Group |
Mean Value |
Standard Deviation |
Mean Difference |
t Value |
1 |
Experimental
group |
||||
Pre test |
94.57 |
11.84 |
|||
Post test |
59.8 |
14.25 |
34.77 |
20.27*** |
|
2 |
Control Group |
||||
Pre test |
94.23 |
12.59 |
|||
Post test |
93.27 |
13.03 |
0.86 |
1.58ns |
***Significant at
P<0/001 level
Figure
4: Mean level of anxiety for experimental and control group during pretest and
post test
Table
4 Frequency, Percentage, and χ2 analysis of Level of Anxiety
among Alcoholics with their Selected Demographic Variables N=60
S No |
Demographic Variables |
Mild level |
Moderate
level |
Chi square χ2 |
||
n |
% |
n |
% |
|||
1 |
Age in
years a) Less
than 18 b) 19 - 25 c) 26 - 40 d) 41
& above |
3 3 5 2 |
5 5 8.33 3.33 |
4 6 19 18 |
6.67 10 31.67 30 |
4.17NS df = 3 |
2 |
Religion a) Hindu b) Muslim c)Christian d)Others |
11 0 2 0 |
18.33 0 3.33 0 |
35 7 5 0 |
58.33 11.67 8.33 0 |
1.38NS df=2 |
3 |
Education a)Primary b)Higher
Secondary c)Graduate |
9 1 3 |
15 1.67 5 |
21 16 10 |
35 26.67 16.67 |
3.84NS df =2 |
4 |
Marital
Status a)Married b)Unmarried c)Divorce |
3 10 0 |
5 16.67 0 |
28 13 6 |
46.67 21.67 10 |
10.75* df=3 |
5 |
Type Of
Family a)Joint
Family b)Nuclear
Family |
2 11 |
3.33 18.33 |
26 21 |
43.33 35 |
6.54* df=1 |
6 |
Occupation a)Self
Employee b)Employed c)Un
employed |
6 7 0 |
10 11.67 0 |
26 21 0 |
43.33 35 0 |
0.57NS df=2 |
7 |
Monthly
Income In Rupees a)Less
Than 2000 b)2001 -
3000 c)3001 -
4000 d)4000 And Above |
1 4 1 7 |
1.67 6.67 1.67 11.67 |
3 6 12 26 |
5 10 20 43.33 |
3.49NS df=3 |
8 |
Duration
Of Alcoholism a)Less
than one year b)2 -
3Years c)4 -
5Years d)Above 5
Years |
2 3 5 3 |
3.33 5 8.33 5 |
6 14 13 14 |
10 23.33 21.67 23.33 |
0.54NS df=3 |
* -
Significant at p < 0.05 level; NS-
Not significant
Table 3 reveals the mean, standard deviation, mean Among 30
samples in an experimental group the pre test score reveals majority 24(80%) of
the samples had moderate level of anxiety, one fifth 6(20%) were under mild
level of anxiety, none of them were under normal level of anxiety, the post
test assessment score of the samples indicates majority 21(70%) of the samples
were under mild level of anxiety and samples with normal level of anxiety were
5(16.67%) and sample with moderate level of anxiety were 4(13.33%).
Table 2.2 depicts frequency and percentage distribution of
level of anxiety in control group. Among 30 samples in control group the pre
test score reveals majority 23(76.67%) of the samples had moderate level of
anxiety, a little above one fifth 7(23.33%) were under mild level of anxiety,
the post test assessment score of the samples indicates a little above three
fourth 23(76.67%) of the samples were under moderate level of anxiety, 7
(23.33%) were mild level of anxiety and none of them were under normal level of
anxiety Section III : Effectiveness of Pranayama on level of anxiety among
Alcoholics..
difference, and `t value for experimental and control
group, Among 30 samples in an experimental group the mean pre test score 94.57
and standard deviation 11.84 was more than mean post test score 59.8 with
standard deviation 14.25. The calculated mean difference is 34.77 and the
obtained `t value is 20.27, which is statistically significant at p< 0.001
level hence it was inferred that Pranayama is an effective in reducing level of
anxiety among alcoholics. Among 30 samples in control group the mean pre test
score 94.23 and standard deviation 12.59 was more than mean post test score
93.27 with standard deviation 13.03. The calculated mean difference is 0.86 and
obtained t value was 1.58 which was not statistically significant at p<0.001
level.
Section IV: Association between the levels of anxiety among
Alcoholics with Selected Demographic Variables.
DISCUSSION:
The basic aim of the current study is to evaluate the effectiveness
of Pranayama on level of anxiety among the alcoholics. The study has been
conducted by using Quasi-experimental design at Wisdom hospital de–addiction
center at Chennai. The total sample size was 60 among which 30 samples were
placed each in control and in experimental group.
The structured self administered STAI scale Spielberger
(1979) was administered to assess the level of anxiety among the alcoholics.
The responses were analyzed through descriptive statistics (mean, frequency,
percentage) and inferential statistics (paired `t` test and Chi-square).
Anxiety is something most people go through almost as a
matter of course, on a regular basis. There are degrees of severity, however,
and based on this psychiatrists have classified them into three types, namely
general anxiety, phobias and panic disorder. Some amount of anxiety we are told
is actually a good thing because it acts as an alarm when danger is close.B3
However, if you are always anxious about everything and nothing and anxious
about being anxious on top of that, then it is a vicious cycle, which can
impair your normal day-to-day, functioning. Whatever the case, be it phobia,
panic or general anxiety, there are implications for the person’s social,
emotional well being and in some cases even their physical well being.
One of the ways in which anxiety can be managed is through
the regular practice of Pranayama. Pranayama is an age-old technique developed
by the Yogis of ancient India as the key to inner wellness. Pranayama is the
technique of breath manipulation to achieve desired level of physical and
emotional wellness.
According to Gautama. (2000) Yoga and meditation are
gaining world wide popularity among people. It is not possible for many of us
to practice yoga religiously after a hard day’s work. Breathing exercise does
not take away our energy. It is a kind of relaxation in which our consciousness
is alert in Pranayama. It’s indeed amazing that sitting and breathing evenly
can be a means of tapping deeper resources within us. Devoting half an hour a
day even for a week reveals the beauty of this practice. It increases the
quality of alertness of the mind, which becomes capable of looking fresh and
thinking in completely new ways. Breathing is not only the nourishment of our
body but it is also the one essential link between the terrestrial and the vast
expanse of cosmos.
Molton. I, et. al., (2005) Pranayama on anxiety management
technique improves quality of life in alcoholism. The current study evaluated
the efficacy of a 6 days, group-based, Pranayama intervention in reducing
anxiety Improving Quality Of Life (QOL) among alcoholics. The study reveals
that 6 days Pranayama group Intervention was effective in improving the QOL by
reducing anxiety among Alcoholics.
The findings of the study were discussed according to the
objectives to evaluate the effectiveness of Pranayama on level of anxiety among
alcoholics.
Among 30 samples in an experimental group the mean pre test
score 94.57 and standard deviation 11.84 was more than mean post test score
59.8 with standard deviation 14.25. The calculated mean difference is 34.77 and
the obtained ´t´ value is 20.27, which is statistically significant at
p<0.001 levels, hence it is inferred that Pranayama is an effective
intervention in reducing anxiety among alcoholics. (Table-3)
Among 30 samples in control group the mean pre test score
94.23 and standard deviation 12.59 was more than mean post test score 93.27
with standard deviation 13.03. The calculated mean difference is 0.86 and
obtained ‘t’ value is 1.58 which is not statistically significant at 0.05
level. (Table-3)
In a research conducted by the National Institute of Mental
Health and Neuroscience in India on July 2006, states that up to 73 percent of
participants with anxiety had a significant reduction while practicing
Sudharshan Kriya Yoga (SKY), a Pranayama technique.
Nutrition Group, Agharkar Research Institute, (2006)
compared the efficacy of SKY against both guided imagery and the drug diazepam.
In this study, consisting of 37 participants and taking place over a period of
7 weeks, researchers found that, although inferior to guided imagery, SKY was
shown to be as effective as diazepam in the treatment of anxiety. During the
study, participants practiced 30 minute daily sessions and once-weekly 75
minute sessions of SKY. Lastly, although more clinical studies are needed to
support the findings, Sudarshan Kriya Yoga has also been shown to be clinically
effective in the treatment of anxiety. Studies also suggest that regular practice
of SKY lowers levels of epinephrine in the blood, and increases an individual’s
overall sense of well-being.
Second objective of the present study is to determine the
association between level of anxiety among alcoholics with their selected
demographic variables. (Age, Religion, education, marital status, type of
family, occupation, monthly income, duration of addiction). The results in the
present study shows the presence of statistically significant relationship
between alcoholics and marital status (χ2=10.5, P = 0.05), and family (χ2=6.54,
P =0.05).
Raj. K (2010) studied the
level of anxiety and effect of family on drug addicts in her study she states
disorganized family environment is considered as one of the key parameter that
makes a normal us individual to get inclined to the world of drug addiction,
her study results concluded that the non addicts family environment is for
better supportive and organized than addicts at 0.001 level of significance.
Tehran (2006)., in his
research suggest that environmental influences are important on the association
between sleep problems and anxiety in adults the results shows the strongest
correlations with sleep problems (R=.20,.21…respectively)and with anxiety (R =
.24,.28 subsequently analysis indicated that family disorganization and mental
depression are occupied for approximately 30% of the association between sleep
problems and anxiety. (R= .18).
Raskin, H. et. al 2005
conducted a longitudinal study on marriage and mental health of a cohort of
young adults in his study reveals that Married people are stress, anxiety and
depressed and have fewer alcohol related problems, as compared to unmarried
people. The rate of alcohol problems and depression is faster in married
people, than in unmarried people. Married men report fewer cases of alcohol
related problems. Better mental health fails to show relationship with length
of marriage and presence of children. The quality of marriage may be
responsible for the relationship between mental health and marriage.
Allan. V (2006) conducted
a comparative study on psychological and mental health of young adolescents who
have cohabited and the married and the unmarried persons. Results show that
there are significant differences in the levels of anxiety of the two groups.
However, alcohol problems are found to be prevalent in married and single
individuals compared to unmarried male and female cohabitates. When a person
living in a joint family, responsibilities and role will be more and family
genetics plays a predominant role to increased anxiety level, marital status
also plays a vital role to raise a anxiety level because of increases demand in
their effort due to role transition.
SUMMARY, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
Major study findings include
Among alcoholics with
moderate level of anxiety, majority of them were between 26 – 40 years, Hindus,
married, 2-3 years duration of addiction. Regarding the level of
anxiety in experimental and control group majority of them were reported to
have moderate level of anxiety, on day 6th most of them reported to have mild
level of anxiety in experimental group and there were no measurable difference
in control group.
With regard to
effectiveness of Pranayama on level of anxiety among the alcoholics the
calculated mean difference is 34.77 and obtained ‘t’ value is
20.27 which it is statistically significant at p<0.001 level, hence it was
inferred that Pranayama is an effective in reducing anxiety among alcoholics.
●
With regard to the association between the level of anxiety their selected
demographic variables such Age, Religion, education, Occupation, Monthly
Income, Marital Status, Type of Family, Duration of Addiction there were
statistical significant association between level of anxiety and type of family
and marital status {( χ2=
6.54,P < 0.005),( χ22=
10.75, P < 0.005)}.
CONCLUSION:
The main
conclusion from the present study is that majority of the alcoholics in an
experimental group had moderate and mild level of anxiety during pre-test and
at the time of post test they had reduction in level of anxiety from moderate
to mild level and mild to normal level. This shows the imperative need to
understand the purpose of Pranayama (SKY) technique regarding reduction of
anxiety among the alcoholics and it will improve the quality of life.
IMPLICATIONS OF THE STUDY:
According to
Tolima, (1995) the section of the research report that focuses on nursing
implication usually includes specific suggestions for nursing practice, nursing
education, nursing administration and nursing research.
Nursing Practice:
The findings of
the study clearly points out that Pranayama (SKY) intervention are effective on
reducing level of anxiety among alcoholics.
The reduction of
anxiety among alcoholics had an important role to play in enabling effectiveness
of Pranayama intervention as an independent nursing intervention. This can be
facilitated by motivating the nurses to:
● Develop
sensitivity to the effects of Pranayama on reducing level of anxiety among the
alcoholics.
●
Understand the importance of Pranayama technique intervention as a adjunct to
the Pharmacological therapy.
● Encourage
peer use of Pranayama intervention as a form of relaxation among the alcoholics
with anxiety.
● Encourage
the use of Pranayama intervention in reduction of anxiety and to minimize the
requirement of non-pharmacological management.
Nursing Education
Health personnel
may separate the theory and practice while treating the alcoholics with anxiety
and tend to reduce the level anxiety which can be beneficial for the
alcoholics. So nursing educators should motivate students to:
● Ensure
that nursing students learn to assess anxiety and effectiveness of Pranayama
intervention in reduction of anxiety, as an independent nursing intervention.
● Provide
adequate clinical exposure to students, where Pranayama is used in reduction of
anxiety.
● Arrange
for participating capacity building program on Pranayama techniques Ensure the
availability of enough literature related to Pranayama techniques in reduction
of anxiety in library, for students reference.
Nursing Administration:
●
Collaborate with hospital authorities in formulating policies to employ the
specially qualified nurses in de – addiction ward and periodically supervise
their application of Pranayama intervention.
● Conduct
capacity building programme on Pranayama intervention and it’s application in
various fields.
● Provide
opportunity for nurses to attend training programme on Pranayama techniques
while handling the alcoholics with anxiety.
Nursing Research
● Encourage
further research studies on the effectiveness of Pranayama intervention in
treating other mental illnesses.
● As it is
evident from the review of literature more research needs to be conducted on
the effectiveness of Pranayama intervention along with other routine procedure,
in reduction of anxiety among other population.
●
Disseminate the findings through the conferences, seminars publication in
Professional, national and international journals and World Wide Web.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
● The study
can be replicated with large sample size.
● The study
can be conducted on patients with drug abuse
● A study
can be conducted to assess the knowledge, attitude and practice of pranayama
among nurses posted in de – addiction ward.
●
Comparative study can be conducted between Pranayama and other relaxation
therapies to reduce level of anxiety among alcoholics
REFERENCES:
1.
Basavanthappa BT. Nursing Research. 1st ed. New
Delhi: Jaypee Brothers; 2003.
2.
Basavanthappa BT. Psychiatric Mental Health
Nursing. 1st ed. New Delhi: Jaypee Brothers Medical Publishers; 2009.
3.
Burns N, Groove SK. THE Practice of Nursing
Research. 5th ed. Missouri: Elsevier Saunders Publications; 2005.
4.
Dr Lalitha K. Mental Health and Psychiatric
Nursing an Indian Perspective. 2nd ed. Bangalore: VMG Book House; 2005.
5.
Forthinash KM. Psychiatric Mental Health Nursing.
4th ed. Canada: Mosby Elsevier Publication; 2008.
6.
Jacob A. Handbook of Psychiatric Nursing. 2nd
ed. Delhi: Vikas Publishing House; 2002.
7.
Nambi S. Psychiatry for Nurses. 1st ed. New
Delhi: Jaypee Brothers Publication; 2005.
8.
Polit F, Beck. Nursing Research Principles and
Methods.7th ed. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams and Wilkins Company; 2005.
9.
Polit F, Hungler D. Nursing Research Principles
and Methods. 5th ed. Philadelphia: J.B. Lippincott Publication; 2001.
10.
Potter and Perry. Fundamentals of Nursing. 4th
ed. Missouri: Mosby Publication; 2001. Rao S, Richard PS. AN Introduction to
Biostatistics. 3rd ed. New Delhi: Prentice-Hall of India Private Ltd; 2004.
11.
Shives LR. Basic Concept of psychiatric Mental
Health Nursing. 17th ed. Philadelphia: Lippincott Publication; 2006.
12.
Sreevani R. A Guide to Mental health and
Psychiatric Nursing. 2nd ed. New Delhi: Jaypee Brothers; 2007.
13.
Stuart GW. Principles and Practice of
Psychiatric Nursing. 9th ed. Missouri: Mosby Elsevier Publication; 2009.
14.
Townsend MC. Essentials of Psychiatric Mental
Health Nursing, 5th ed. Philadelphia: F.A. Davis Company; 2007.
15. Wesley
L, Ruby. Nursing Theories and Models. 2nd ed. Pennsylvania: Spring House
Publication; 1992
16.
Beitman BD., (2010)., “The Relation between
alcohol problems an the anxiety disorders”., Society For The Study Of
Addiction., V (45) I (4): 283-287.
17.
Mc Gilbert., (2004)., “The lowdown on families
who get high: successful parenting for families affected by addiction”., CWLA
Press: 12.
18.
Horwitz et al., (2005)., “ Becoming married and
mental health: A longitudinal study of a Cohort of Young adults”., Journal Of Marriage and the
Family. V (15) I (2): 436-439.
19.
India’s Alcohol Profile, The Hindhu. Daily
Saturday, May 03, 2008
20.
N. Janakiramaiah.,(2000)., “Anti-depressant
efficacy of sudarshan Kriya Yoga (SKY) in melancholia”., Journal of Affective
Disorders , V(57)I(1 – 3): 255 – 259.
21.
Jinu K (2009),, “Effects of Alcoholism on
Adolesent Boys” journal of Nightingale
nursing times, v (5) no (6); 45-4
22.
Murali M, S.(2010). Epidemiological study of
Prevalence of mental disorders in India Indian Journal of Community Medicine.
26(4): 201-204)
23.
Richard P. Brown., Patricia L. Gerang., (2005).,
“Alcoholic patients with anxiety” The Journal of Alternative and Complementary
Medicine. V (11) I (4): 711- 717.
24.
Scott KM et al., (2010)., “Gender and
relationship between marital status and first onset of mood, anxiety and
substance use disorders”., Psycho Med., V(40)I(9): 1495-1505.
25.
Shashi Ajit Chiplonkar., (2008)., “Pranayama for
depression Andanxiety”., Alternative and Complementary Therapies., V(14)I(2):
96-100.
26.
White et al., (2002)., “The relationship of
Cohabilitation and mental health”., Journal of Marriage and The Family.,
V(9)I(6): 276-280.
27. Sahoo
(2010). Prevalence of Depression, Anxiety, and stress among young male adults
in India: a dimensional and Categorical diagnoses-based study The Journal of,
Nervous and mental disease.198 (12): 901-4.
28.
Al-anon faces alcoholism, www.aanon.alateen
Dated on 2010.
29.
Alcohol Use Disorders and Anxiety Disorders,
www.maenoch.dicbr.niaaa.nih.gov/ Dated on 09-06-2005.
30.
Anxiety and Drinking Behavior, www.aboutdoi.com
Dated on 8-02-2004.
31.
Effects of breathing in addiction,
http://www.liebertonline.com/doi/abs/10.1089/acm.2005.11.711 Dated on Apr 2010.
32.
Exploring Difference between Community based
women and men with a history of mental illness, www.ncbi.nlm.nic/pubmed Dated
on 19-08-09.
33.
Factors related to alcohol and drug consumption,
www.ncbi.nlm.nic/pubmed Dated on 22-03-09.
34.
Facts about alcoholism, www.valueoptions.com
Dated on 2005.
35.
Family difference levels of anxiety on marriage
status in single men and women, http://www.gunadarma.ac.id Dated on 20-08-2006.
36.
Level of Anxiety and Effect of Family
Environment on Drug Addicts, http://www.krepublishers.com/ Dated on 03-06-10.
37.
Pranayama and the Art of Breathing,
www.yogasite.com Dated on 21-03-2003.
38.
Pranayama a guide to conscious breathing,
www.bhaktinova.com Dated on 12-06-2004.
39.
The healing breath technique/sudarshan kriya in
the treatment of depression, www.researchartofliving.com Dated on 23-04-2004.
40.
The Science of Pranayama, http://www.dlshq.org/cgi-bin/
Dated on 03-08-2008.
41.
Yoga and Addiction International Association of
Yoga Therapists, www.iayt.org , Dated on 2005.
Received on 01.06.2015 Modified on 11.06.2015
Accepted on 26.06.2015 ©
A&V Publication all right reserved
Int. J. Nur. Edu. and
Research 3(3):July-Sept., 2015; Page 299-309
DOI: 10.5958/2454-2660.2015.00012.5